74 points 13 hours ago Edit see my self reply below for explanation of why this comment examines what it does while ignoring other important areas of this broad and complex problem I think this should also make us more sympathetic to the enormity of the choices we casually foisted on our ancestors and made them responsible for And I am not here diminishing the magnitude of past genocides on the contrary I mean to emphasize them With this data the only moral choice directly available to stop this is war invasion of China by other powers and imposition of martial law to the extent that victims of these policies are freed and their unjust suffering given reparation insofar as this sort of thing is even possible much about suffering cannot be undone and certainly you cannot pay for the dead in a way that makes up for their loss to the living Because that is what we mean by responsible right? That our ancestors stood by as the Holocaust or some other genocide unfolded and allowed it to continue Certainly there are other ways of bringing pressure against nation- states but there is little hope of gaining the sort of international unity that could make this effective against a state with an economy as diversified as China's Only war is credible here because other countries would suffer incredible deprivation by opposing China and worry about the unequal competition with other nations that choose to continue reading with China Sanctions work to a degree against Russia but people should understand that this is because of its much less diversified economy hitting on just one or two coordinated fronts is very effective and Russia does not have reliable capital moneyasset protection making asset seizingfreezing in finance hubs like London and the US effective Additionally their best goods such as natural gas can be gotten from elsewhere albeit not as cheaply giving huge importers of those resources like Germany enormous leverage not buying starts a price spiral that hurts Russia far more than Germany China on the other hand is a linchpin of the global economy and in many areas is essentially the sole provider of many rare raw materials like rare earth magnets used in electronics as well as many manifactured goods Its economy is also roughly self-sufficient it can technically feed itself and outfit armies start to finish in a pinch even if that's far from ideal economically As a result and in addition to its unique and historically unprecedented role in the global economy no nation has ever worn this many hats in this particular way most economic options for political pressure actually hurt everyone else much more than China which completely changes the calculus That in turn makes those economic options for diplomacy largely ineffective even if you can get countries on-board which you basically can't Ever wonder why we hear about strict sanctions on small or isolated countries like CubaNorth Korea or global powers like Russia but not really China? That's why Not very effective hurts everyone else more and too many countries fear not having access to the Chinese economycompeting against other countries that are happy to continue importing inexpensive Chinese goods This is one reason why China insists on domestic companies only at the helm of its economy andor forces technology transfers and domestic partnerships on any Western company entering its market and probably the most important one Many centuries of subjugation by Western powers through economic warfare has hardened its resolve to not be vulnerable to this problem ever again So this circumstance is not coincidental in the least and it limits what political levers other nations can apply to China without war Paradoxically this increases instability in a way from a global perspective because it means conflict resolution short of war is very difficult to force China to the table on as we have frequently seen when China ignores international treaties with impunity But an actual war a real war a war that would not stop until these oppressed peoples were free would lead to unimaginable suffering on a global scale The refugees alone would overwhelm the stability of East AsiaCentral Europe Millions at least would die directly in war even if China did not ultimately result to nuclear weapons or other weapons of mass destruction They are a great power on the way to becoming a global superpower the world has not seen a conflict like that since WW2 even if only the US and China fought and certainly other nations would be drawn in including at minimum former superpower Russia and North Korea where Chinese divisions decimated American forces during the Korean War at troop strength rations of 12 divisions or more to each American division The world has never seen the central nations of a globally interconnected world economy at war The amount of knock on suffering caused by that economic turmoil is probably incalculable The Great Recession in 2012 would look tiny in comparison The limited trade war initiated by President Trump is already having global impacts on the economy and that is simply tariff trading not complete disconnection and war And if I focus on the US here it's primarily for two reasons One because it is the superpower that made human rights a matter of politics after the Holocaust Before its global hegemony and the catastrophe that brought it to the head of that hegemony what a nation did to its people was considered its own business This is to both its glory and its shame a rare international and historical triumph of morality to be responsible for and a magnification of the shame of its own human rights abuses and its intermittent strategic befriending of those who have committed them already For example how many people know that it is the US that forced Britain to divest its empire and allow the independent self-determination of its subjugated peoples? This was a direct requirement imposed by the United States if Britain wanted to be included at the treaty after the end of WW2 The US also directly and successfully opposed Anglo-Soviet plans for carving up other countries as spoils of war notwithstanding the annexations the Soviet Union began before the treaty was even concluded and continued in the immediate aftermath Consider also things like the Alien Torts act a statute that underwent a legal revival in the modern era in which US courts allowed foreigners to bring suits against other foreigners for crimes against humanity committed in foreign countries a more substantial threat to dictators than it might seem due to the US's role as a global finance and capital hub which meant assets of dictators or other person's could be frozen or seized by court order and travel to the US impossible in practice People focus on the hypocrisy of the US here but honestly it is not the hypocrisy that is remarkable at all We would expect nations to do nasty things in their own interest and they usually do It is a little remarked on miracle that the US is directly responsible for human rights being seen as legitimate political objective at all it was and is a completely unprecedented occurrence in human history The second reason is that it is only the US that would have a credible chance of invading China and succeeding and odds are quite good that even this credible chance would end in failure as force projection for a smalll amount of time anywhere in the world the specialty of the US and its expertise by far is much different than total war predicated on supply chains thousands of miles long Where this is occurring in China is possibly one of the the worst places for it to occur too in terms of this military difficulty Even a multinational force of smaller nations with modern militaries would pose no credible threat of total war on China such is the state of her military power already at this early date in her rise Even a truly global coalition ie not a nominally global but practically unilateral coalition like the one that invaded Iraq in 2003 has a moderate chance of failure- China's geography in particular disfavors any inland invasion coming from the sea Without the US any such effort is likely doomed to failure So the problem is especially acute the sole actor that can add the value needed to make the conflict worthwhile has a lonely spotlight to sit under Only it can credibly act and hence it alone must also carry the shame of inaction if chosen With great power comes great responsibility as Uncle Ben noted How terrible are the options we are left with To let the innocent suffer and be effectively silent what good does awareness without change do? or to wage war and cause equal or worse suffering but arguably as moral victors As someone who fought in a war much more limited and low intensity than this I cannot express just how much misery war results in It is never an option to be chosen lightly There are literally no winners in war other than armament industries and nation-statess moneyed interests and abstractions and maybe in very rare cases future generations Every actual person involved loses even as the victors I don't even know whether to be disappointed in us all I am sure no war will come but is this a good thing or a bad thing? Are we too standing by during the Holocaust? Such an ugly and dispiriting circumstance I feel like it gives me more sympathy for the onlookers who still scarred by wW1 and even threatened themselves were still too skittish for war And of course even more sympathy for the victims of that genocide and that war and their modern day counterparts My heart cries out for these people They live between what is for other nations the frying pan and the fire permalink embed unsave parent report give award reply - 23 points 12 hours ago Minor note as reply to myself other comment already at character limit I am not ignoring the evidence of China's internal struggle over this a struggle that may we can only hope eventually result in the freedom of these people being persecuted for practicing their religion peacefully Rather I am focusing on one aspect of the issue the position of Western non-China nations in this equation as well as their available options for resolution This is certainly a much broader issue than that and China's internal politics as well as the victims themselves are more important and central than what I chose to examine here The reason for my narrow focus was simply this thinking about what we as people of Western nations can actually and directly do as opposed to any options that rely on China deciding on her own agency to stop if we agree that responsibility falls on our shoulders when known genocide is met with inaction as is mentioned in the submission statement For a number of reasons some of which I gave here I am fairly sure that war is the only directly efficacious means of ensuring that aim China may or may not change her internal policy but if she does it won't be because of Western economic or political pressure Hence if it is true we are morally responsible for inaction during genocide it seems that in this case it would mean a moral obligation to go to war an option with its own extremes of suffering and nearly guaranteed to be a calamity of global scope Which is not very different at all from WW2 as it was then the war that eventually did occur was in fact a global calamity and hence the choice that we fault our ancestors for not going to war over human rights is very similar to what we exp to see the war that would have resulted for other reasons And hence the now except we opportunity to see just how much suffering a choice to make war over genocide would have created if our ancestors had actually acted This extremely unappetizing choice between moral war and immoral inaction is what prompted my comment permalink embed save parent report give award reply Troubled redditor pens a long essay on whether the Western nations have the moral obligation of invading China in order to stop genocide Meme

Being alone

Bad

Complex

Disappointed

Empire

finance

Fire

Frozen

Future

head

Money

nasty

north korea

Politics

Pressure

Struggle

The Worst

True

Ugly

China

Work

Access

Alien

American

Best

Business

Capital

Chinese

Cuba

Date

Earth

Europe

Express

Focus

Free

Germany

Good

Happy

Heart

History

Holocaust

Iraq

Limited

Live

London

Mean

Opportunity

Power

Quite

Russia

Suits

Technology

Time

Travel

Trump

United

Unity

What Is

World

Korean

Military

Britain

Historical

International

Soviet

Western

Change

Diplomacy

Failure

Fear

Freedom

Hope

Humanity

Hypocrisy

Leverage

Living

Martial

Morality

Never

Nuclear Weapons

Reason

Religion

Responsibility

Soviet Union

Suffering

The State

They Live

Wonder

Total War

A Matter

Board

how

superpower

freezing

powers

united states

pan

ww2

her

add

korean war

human

company

ww1

korea

asia

act

table

calculus

misery

triumph

war

wanted

lead

data

division

who

character

natural gas

mass

rare

shame

aim

policy

glory

can

raw

one

president

law

total

spiral

union

degree

case

tiny

force

resolution

weapons

genocide

era

hats

nation states

the independent

comparison

options

may

invasion

martial law

means

hub

great recession

market

day

why

reading

the holocaust

will

she

think

geography

own

did

them

edit

all

rare earth

counterparts

the world

huge

the the

make

human rights

they

thing

chosen

you

evidence

court

economy

modern

real

comment

ideal

now

person

trading

price

chance

note

agency

scope

example

projection

what

hurts

troop

scale

perspective

recession

aspect

still

made

uncle ben

order

for

below

conflict

moral

east asia

east

option

states

strength

companies

reply

intermittent

human history

issue

central

frying pan

economic

conflict resolution

used

knock

global economy

anglo

look

incredible

rare earth magnets

reliable

embed

more

magnitude

with great power comes great responsibility

this

why not

get

of course

really

do it

lonely

stop

political

great

thinking

like

sure

right

dead

feel

this is

making

parent

worst

problem

people

well

what a

such

different

turn

continue

chose

probably

hand

the end

just

catastrophe

then

possible

innocent

because

end

aftermath

impossible

explanation

technically

destruction

eventually

everyone

might

someone

if only

remarkable

worry

coming

certainly

enormous

those

examine

practicing

in particular

seen

including

myself

decimated

drawn

for example

practically

i think

on the other hand

seems

here i am

needed

fairly

my heart

ignoring

as well

doomed

enormity

focusing

unique

hegemony

albeit

sympathy

miracle

literally

uncle

except

impunity

particular

notwithstanding

maybe

rely

scarred

their

substantial

ever

go to

terrible

matter

efficacious

usually

gotten

objective

coalition

essentially

hence

skittish

allow

gas can

sufficient

actual

suffer

were

rather

submission

imposition

turmoil

broad

moderate

there

fault

contrary

extent

began

reasons

emphasize

credible

too

fact

worthwhile

the frying pan

asset

calamity

choose

resolve

self sufficient

state

sympathetic

treaty

noted

subjugation

through

intensity

interest

determination

no

see

things

hours

die

way

come

know

left

agree

understand

ago

much

like that

else

in the world

ben

exp

two

sea

hear

pens

dont

hurt

pose

acute

essay

again

actor

short

small

award

already

choices

nuclear

the way

changes

carving

there is

on board

provider

too many

oppressed

feel like

difficult

ancestors

spotlight

completely

not really

competition

i dont even

electronics

magnification

how many people

it-is-true

out

over

natural

over-this

self

hitting

i am sure

dispiriting

the choice

unprecedented

shoulders

little

13 hours

threat

And

Other

U S

Here

I Am

Cant

Outfit

Loss

Winners

Equation

Both

Gas

When

Choice

This Is War

Number

Actually

Honestly

Dont Even

Simply

I Dont Even Know

That

Finish

Forced

But

Not

Legal

Miles

Cries

Where

Effort

Is This

That Hurts

Independent

How Much

Give

Asset Protection

The

Early

War On

Not The

President Trump

Long

By Far

Trade

A Good

Magnets

From

Basically

Points

Value

Important

Thinking About

On The Way

Refugees

Protection

The One

Past

Plans

Report

Save

Rights

Its

This Many

Practice

Every

Starts

Many

Silent

During

Redditor

On One

The U

Odds Are

A Little

I E

Cannot

S And

Especially

Amount

Very

Deciding

Sit

Role

Becoming

These

Without

Falls

Goods

Pinch

The Fire

While

Sole

Start

Overwhelm

After

Feed

Ways

Results

Met

Such As

At Least

Linchpin

Possibly

Legitimate

Obligation

Vulnerable

Does Not

I Dont

Thats

Rise

Countries

Was

With

Cause

Narrow

Let

Future Generations

Result

Revival

Low

Warfare

Our

Comes

In A

12 Hours

Should

Awareness

Are

Have

Nation

Persons

Statement

Going

If You

The War

Continued

With Great Power

I Cannot

Great Power Comes Great Responsibility

Had

And That

Seized

I Mean

Also

I Feel

Seizing

Gave

Casually

I Am Not

Standing By

Not Going

Not Going To

Available

Pay

The Limited

How Many

Which

Only

About

Chains

Does

Global

Truly

Foreign

Centuries

Guaranteed

Between

Complete

Since

Domestic

Expertise

Has

Resources

Immediate

Before

Peoples

Meant

Being

Most

Against

Extremely

Acted

Central Europe

Far

Freed

Good Thing

Internal

Minimum

Must

North

Position

Supply

The Dead

The Great

The United States

Giving

The Most Important

Expect

Limits

Bring

I Feel Like

Just One

Limit

A Good Thing

Second

Great Responsibility

Responsible

Succeeding

Partnerships

Troubled

Equal

Than

Wage

Standing

Odds

Generations

Seem

Inaction

Worse

Immoral

Moral Obligation

Unjust

Themselves

Difficulty

Buying

Involved

Competing

Committed

Given

Crimes

Known

Stood

Hardened

Even

Elsewhere

Self Determination

Circumstance

Some

Dictators

Worn

Thousands

Carry

Course

Could

Forces

It Was

War Is

Fought

Having

Consider

Whether

Tariff

Arguably

As Is

Assets

Divest

Hitting On

Inexpensive

Less

On The Contrary

Roughly

Sort

Spoils Of War

Strict

Thats Why

If She

A Bad

A Long

A Rare

About The

Addition

After The

Am Not

And Is

Any

Apply

Be Vulnerable

Because It Is

Before The

Brought It

But Not Really

Character Limit

Complex Problem

Concluded

Could Be

Deprivation

Does It

Effective

Essay On

Even More

Fear Not

For The

Frying

Go To War

Going To War

Have A

I Am Not Here

If I

If You Can

Importing

In China

In Human

In The

Increases

Internal Struggle

Invading

Is A

Is Not

Is That It

Is That

It Is

It Means

It Seems

Know That

Little Hope

Make The

Many Hats

Materials

Millions

Minor

Most Important

Multinational

Non

Not A

Not Here

On A

Pay For

Places

To Do

A Matter Of

A Number Of

Additionally

And Or

Anywhere

Armament

Similar

As A Result

As Opposed To

As Well As

At All

At The Helm

Because Of

Brought

Coincidental

Considered

Coordinated

Court Order

Direct

Directly

Due

Due To

Each

Economically

Effectively

End In

Even As

Even If

Former

Frequently

Great Power

Helm

Historically

In A Pinch

In Practice

Incalculable

Ineffective

Initiated

Inland

Insofar

Insofar As

Instability

Interconnected

Isolated

Itself

Knock On

Largely

Lead To

Least

Lightly

Likely

Modern Day

Moneyed

More Than

Much Less

Nearly

Nominally

Occur

Occurrence

On A Global Scale

One Many

Opposed

Other Than

Predicated

Primarily

Reparation

Requirement

Result In

Short Of

Smaller

Some Other

Sort Of

Specialty

Stability

Statute

Strategic

Terms

The Contrary

The Most

The Other

They Are

Threatened

To Let

To Be

Is This A

gives

you can

against humanity

would

hours ago

e

to go

that could

until

i gave

that may

me

victims

was a

that would

reason why

even know

cases

my

created

loses

have committed

what i

wont

if it

we are

makes

us

who have

those who

permalink

mass destruction

like it

going to

2012

s

everyone else

someone who

can only

ever again

see my

sanctions

a great

nations

we have

bringing

would die

would not

would have

can be

would be

globally

who still

bad thing

under

at

allowed

i chose

that even

ignores

entering

to see

some of

end of

her own

effective against

that makes

as we

there are

am sure

an actual

actual person

only hope

can get

made them

literally no

courts

impacts

trade war

gaining

may not

here i

with great power comes

that made

a

it

found ON 2019-11-18 02:06:09 BY astrologymemes.com

source: reddit